At the request of the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) participants, the Delta Science Program has convened an Independent Science Review Panel (Panel) to assess the scientific soundness of the BDCP Effects Analysis. The Effects Analysis, a critical component of the BDCP, is intended to provide the best scientific assessment of the likely effects of BDCP actions on the species of concern and the ecological process of the Bay-Delta system. This review is being conducted in multiple phases. The Panel initially convened for an initial (Phase 1) Review on the Draft BDCP Effects Analysis' Conceptual Foundation and Analytical Framework and the Entrainment Appendix as an example of the application of the conceptual understanding, methods and analyses discussed in the Conceptual Foundation and Analytical Framework. In the most recent drafts of the BDCP Effects Analysis, the Foundation and Framework (originally Appendix A) concepts have been incorporated into Chapter 5: Effects Analysis. During Phase 2 of the review, the Panel reviewed the BDCP Chapter 5: Effects Analysis and many of the associated technical appendices. Appendices 5.E: Habitat Restoration and 5.G: Fish Life Cycle Models were not reviewed during the Phase 2 review. The BDCP Chapter 5: Effects Analysis and all of its associated technical appendices will be reviewed during the Phase 3 review.
Click here for more background information
Charge to the Independent Review Panel
The charge to the panel provides the purpose, background, initial list of documents, and specific questions for the panel to start the review process. It provides the direction and context for the review.
Review Panel Members
- Alex Parker, Ph. D., California Maritime Academy, California State University (Panel Chair)
- Charles "Si" Simenstad, Research Professor, University of Washington (Lead Author)
- T. Luke George, Ph.D., Colorado State University
- Nancy Monsen, Ph.D., Stanford University
- Tom Parker, Ph.D., California State University San Francisco
- Greg Ruggerone, Ph.D., Natural Resources Consulting, Inc.
- John Skalski, Ph.D., University of Washington