Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment and Adaptation Strategy
Purpose and Background
At its May 24, 2018 meeting, the Delta Stewardship Council directed staff to begin preparing a Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment (CCVA) and Adaptation Strategy (AS) for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and Suisun Marsh. This work will provide critical support to the Delta Stewardship Council (Council) to improve understanding of regionally specific climate change risks and address how Delta communities, infrastructure, and the ecosystem can adapt to future conditions.
The Delta Reform Act (Act) specifies consideration of “the future impact of climate change and sea level rise” in restoration planning (Water Code Section 85066) and identifies a restoration timeline horizon of 2100 (Water Code Section 85302). The Act also notes that the Delta Plan may address “the effects of climate change and sea level rise on the three state highways that cross the Delta” (Water Code Section 85307). More generally, Executive Order B-30-15, signed by Governor Brown in April 2015, requires state agencies to incorporate climate change into planning and investment decisions. Also, agencies are required to prioritize natural infrastructure and actions for climate preparedness and protection of the most vulnerable populations.
Since the Delta Plan was adopted in 2013, research on climate change has advanced significantly, with important implications for the Council as it seeks to further the coequal goals. Climate change is already altering the physical environment throughout the Delta. Over the long term, climate change in the Delta is expected to adversely affect human health and safety, lead to economic disruptions, diminish water supply, degrade water quality, shift ecosystem function and habitat qualities, and make it more difficult for government agencies to provide basic services. Many of these impacts will disproportionately affect disadvantaged communities, including those located within the Delta.
- Inform future Delta Plan amendments and implementation
- Help the state prioritize future actions and investments
- Provide a toolkit of information for local governments to use and implement in their regulatory documents (what hazards a community is vulnerable to) and adaptation strategies for each hazard
- Serve as a framework to be built upon in the future by the Council and others
Overview and Process
The general project scope reflects statutory requirements of the Act, assets and resources considered in the Delta Plan, and existing Delta Plan policies, recommendations, and performance measures. The project will apply state agency guidance on climate change to the Delta. This will include guidance from the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research (OPR), the California Ocean Protection Council, the California Natural Resources Agency, and the California Coastal Commission for local and regional government engagement and planning.
The graphic below shows the process for developing the CCVA and AS. The Council is currently completing steps 2 and 3: taking inventory of assets and resources and assessing vulnerability. While the Council may monitor portions of the adaptation plan, it is anticipated that implementation of the plan will be undertaken by other agencies.
The project consists of two phases:
Phase 1: Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment (CCVA)
Based on the best available scientific technical information, guidance, and stakeholder engagement, the project will assess climate vulnerability and risk to key sectors, assets and resources, and services. The CCVA will characterize climate change impacts resulting from sea level rise, precipitation and runoff patterns, and air and water temperatures. Climate changes impacts from wildfire, wind, and fog will be addressed qualitatively. Asset sectors to be considered include: water supply and flood management infrastructure, water quality, ecosystems, agriculture, cultural resources, buildings and facilities, parks and recreation, transportation, energy and utilities, and human populations, with particular focus on vulnerable communities. For each asset sector, the CCVA will assess risk of exposure to climate change impacts, sensitivity to climate change, and adaptive capacity and resources to cope with, adapt to, or recover from climate impacts.
Phase 2: Adaptation Strategy (AS)
In this phase, the project will evaluate alternative responses that could be implemented in the Delta region or elsewhere. The AS will evaluate potential responses and provide a toolkit of policy and management actions that state and local agencies could undertake related to each asset sector. Local agencies will be able to decide which adaptation actions are appropriate to implement in their community. Adaptation strategies will enable achievement of resilience goals.
Both the CCVA and AS will identify thresholds for vulnerability, and identify interim adaptation targets between 2020-2100. Planning horizons may include 2030, 2050, and 2100.
In addition to the Council, the following two groups will provide input and guidance to Council staff and consultants throughout the project:
- A Technical Advisory Committee comprised of experts from public agencies, academic institutions, non-profit organizations, the private sector, and individuals with particular knowledge of climate change, the Delta, and its resources will provide input on key analyses and findings.
- A Stakeholder Workgroup representing Delta city/county planning or resource management agencies, community organizations, and interested stakeholders will provide local perspectives for the assessment and strategy, building a constituency for implementation.
The first Stakeholder Workgoup meeting was held on October 2nd, 2019. During this meeting, participants were asked the following questions:
- How do you (or your organization) plan to utilize the Vulnerability Assessment?
- How can the Council prepare the document to maximize its effectiveness?
- What projects or planning efforts are you working on that are related to the Vulnerability Assessment?
Later, participants broke out into small groups to provide input on Delta assets in each of the following categories: natural resources, water supply and flooding, communities, and utilities and facilities. Participants were asked whether any asset types or categories were missing, and whether there were any missing data sources that should be referenced.
Engaging with local and regional Delta government agencies and communities is a fundamental objective of the project. Several local agencies have already adopted climate adaptation policies and recommendations, many of which seek regional collaboration on climate change and sea level rise planning (i.e., Solano County, San Joaquin County, Sacramento County, Yolo County, Contra Costa County, San Joaquin Council of Governments, Sacramento Area Council of Governments). Council staff will continue to engage these agencies to collectively identify adaptation strategies that advance state goals for the Delta while improving both local and regional resilience.
A set of draft resilience goals have been prepared and outline a broad, long-term vision of Delta values and priorities that should persist in the face of a changing climate. The resilience goals will be used throughout the project to evaluate adaptation options, identify trade-offs and synergies, and to prioritize adaptation options that would increase resilience of Delta assets. These draft goals are as follows:
- Promote statewide water conservation, water use efficiency, and sustainable water use (Public Resources Code 85020(d)).
- Improve water quality to protect human health and the environment consistent with achieving water quality objectives in the Delta (Public Resources Code 85020(e)).
- Improve the water conveyance system and expand statewide water storage (Public Resources Code 85020(f)).
- Restore the Delta ecosystem, including its fisheries and wildlife, as the heart of a healthy estuary and wetland ecosystem (Public Resources Code 85020(c)).
- Restore critical physical and biological processes; connectivity; complexity and diversity; redundancy; at large scales with a long time horizon in mind.
- Protect and enhance the unique cultural, recreational, and agricultural values of the California Delta as an evolving place (Public Resources Code 85020(b)).
- Reduce risks to people, property, and state interests in the Delta by effective emergency preparedness, appropriate land uses, and investments in flood protection (Public Resources Code 85020(g)).
- Increase the resilience of Delta communities, especially those with characteristics that make them more vulnerable to climate risk due to physical (built and environmental), social, political, and/or economic factors. These factors include, but are not limited to, race, class, sexual orientation and identification, national origin, and income inequality (OPR 2018).
- Prioritize actions that protect the most vulnerable populations (EO B-30-15).
- Maintain and improve local economic vitality and access to diverse employment opportunities by preserving and growing, where appropriate, key economic and employment drivers and associated infrastructure that support the Delta economy and communities.
- Promote the development of urban growth strategies that reduce climate risks by focusing new development in more resilient areas, enhancing the Delta ecosystem, and supporting resilient farming and recreation activities.
- Improve and enhance the resilience of the Delta transportation network while supporting the achievement of regional and statewide greenhouse gas reduction targets.
- Foster collaboration and build capacity among federal, state, and local agencies, non-governmental and private organizations, and communities in the Delta.
- Commit to working cooperatively to identify and mitigate climate change impacts and risks.
- Improve coordination among regulatory agencies to reduce program or legal barriers to addressing current and future flood, drought, wildfire, and other risks that will be exacerbated by climate change.
- Incorporate climate change into state and local Delta planning and investment decisions (EO B-30-15).
- Prioritize actions that incorporate natural and green infrastructure solutions (EO B-30-15).
- Define the Council’s role in coordinating adaptation responses in the Delta.
Timeline and Key Milestones
Phase 1 of the project began in Spring 2019 and will conclude with a final CCVA in Spring 2020. Phase 2 will begin in Summer 2020 and conclude with an Adaptation Strategy in Summer 2021.